Lawyer opinion: why do immigrant children need citizenship of their parents ’native countries
Second citizenship is a very useful thing. In some cases, citizenship of the native country arises by birth, in other cases it is required to go through the procedure for acquiring citizenship.
For example, in accordance with Russian legislation, a child acquires citizenship of the Russian Federation by birth if both his parents or his only parent are citizens of this country. With different citizenship of the parents, the child acquires the citizenship of the Russian Federation only if born in Russia. If a child is born to parents with different citizenship, say, in the United States, then for the acquisition of Russian citizenship he will need the consent of the second parent or permanent residence in the Russian Federation.
In the situation with Ukraine, for example, a child acquires Ukrainian citizenship if at least one of his parents is a citizen of Ukraine. However, many immigrants ignore the presence of a second citizenship for themselves and their children. A common misconception is that the expiration of a national passport terminates citizenship. This is not true. If an immigrant believes that he will never need the citizenship of his native country again, he must go through the process of renunciation of citizenship.
As for the question of why immigrant children need citizenship of their parents ’home countries, in some cases this citizenship is simply there and should not be ignored.
Having a second citizenship is very convenient when traveling. For example, for a US citizen, you need a visa to visit Russia. This means that the trip needs to be planned in advance, while having a child's Russian passport allows you to buy a plane ticket and fly away on the same day. A Russian visa has certain time limits, and a child must leave Russia before the expiration of the period indicated in the visa.
Recently, the heart-breaking history of a Russian woman living in the USA, who traveled with her American child to Russia, has spread all over the Internet. The girl decided to spend the whole summer with her family, losing sight of the validity periods of her child's visa. As a result, the child could not pass passport control, he was not put on the flight. Mother and son spent many hours at Sheremetyevo airport before the child was issued a visa, and they were able to fly away in two days, spending more than three thousand dollars to purchase new tickets.
Such a situation is not uncommon, many Russian parents fall into such situations regularly, but not everyone writes about it. The presence of a child’s passport in the home country of his parents allows him not only to travel freely to grandparents, but also to stay in the country for as long as necessary, and even live there permanently.
What you need to know about second citizenship
Very often, immigrants do not issue passports to their children, despite the fact that their children have the citizenship of their native country of birth. There are cases when there is no citizenship by birth, and the child’s acquisition of citizenship of the Russian Federation, for example, is the choice of his parents (cases where children are born in families where the parents have different citizenships). In this case, the parents are free to make an independent decision on the acquisition or non-acquisition by their child of Russian citizenship. But in those cases when the child already has citizenship, it is necessary to draw up supporting documents.
The most relevant is the registration of Russian citizenship to Russian girls who have married Americans. Often they become hostages of abusive relationships, sometimes not having the opportunity to go home with a child. Therefore, some particularly advanced Russian wives of Americans prefer to give birth to a child in Russia, where even with different citizenship of the parents, the child will acquire Russian citizenship by birth. Well, US citizenship from such a child will not go anywhere with an American father.
Another plus that many do not think about is the presence of citizenship of their native country helps to minimize taxes when entering the inheritance. For example, a year ago, a U.S. citizen turned to me, whose father died tragically, leaving a luxurious mansion on the Black Sea coast as an inheritance. When entering into the inheritance as a US citizen, she would have to pay such a tax that the mansion would not want to.
But upon closer examination, I realized that she had not lost the citizenship of Ukraine. Despite the fact that for many years she did not support her Ukrainian passport, I advised her to restore the Ukrainian documents, and she filed papers for inheritance not only as a citizen of Ukraine, but also as a Ukrainian resident, which did not raise any questions from the relevant departments and doubt. As a result, she inherited after her father’s death and took over the mansion on the Black Sea coast without paying a penny of the tax provided by Ukraine in such cases for foreigners and persons who are not tax residents of the state. This situation became possible due to the fact that many years ago, leaving for the USA, she did not leave the apartment in Ukraine and retained Ukrainian citizenship.
If you have a second citizenship, keep the supporting documents in order
In addition to the advantages of obtaining citizenship of the home country of immigrants, there are also risks that a refusal to timely renew citizenship documents may entail.
For example, crossing the state border of the Russian Federation without valid documents for the right to enter or exit Russia, or without proper permission obtained in the manner established by the legislation of the Russian Federation, constitutes a crime under Part 1 of Art. 322 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.
In Ukraine, fortunately, these acts were decriminalized, but administrative responsibility nevertheless exists. Administrative responsibility is not only a fine, but also a delay with departure, ticket loss, additional costs.
Any adult citizen of the Russian Federation or Ukraine can withdraw from citizenship on the basis of free will, and in the presence of American citizenship or guarantees of its acquisition, he cannot be denied this. Therefore, there is no need to violate the law: if there is citizenship, you need to draw up the appropriate documents (passport) or, if the fact of having citizenship objectively interferes, you need to get out of citizenship, but do not expire documents and do not violate the regime of entry into their native countries, which their citizens can carry out exclusively on the passports of these countries.
A few years ago, a client contacted me, who needed to issue a power of attorney so that I could finish all her affairs in Russia on her behalf, because after completing all the affairs and selling the property she was going to leave the citizenship of the Russian Federation. The girl was a soldier in the United States, and while moving up the career ladder, she faced a choice: whether to pursue a military career in the United States or to retain Russian citizenship (two in one in her case was impossible). As a result, she withdrew from the citizenship of the Russian Federation and retained her only US citizenship. There are similar restrictions in Russia: some time ago, a federal judge asked me for help. He was a native of Ukraine and in the past had Ukrainian citizenship. Having moved to the Russian Federation in 1994, he lost the citizenship of Ukraine. In 2019, he had to confirm his lack of citizenship other than Russian. There are a lot of similar situations.
Very often people confuse registration of citizenship and registration of a passport with existing citizenship. Some confidently claim that having acquired US citizenship, they have lost the citizenship of their home countries. In most cases this is not the case (although, depending on the country of the second citizenship, there are exceptions). But in relation to Russia and Ukraine, the acquisition of US citizenship does not terminate the existing citizenship of immigrants. Therefore, if in fact there is citizenship, then you need to have a passport.
Citizenship and passport procedures
The passport of a citizen of Russia, Ukraine or Belarus residing in the USA is issued at the Russian consulate. To obtain a Russian passport, it is extremely important that by the time you apply for a new passport, the old passport must be valid. People who did not renew their Russian passport on time often face the need to go through the procedure for confirming citizenship, which on average takes 8-9 months.
Registration for the submission of documents to the Russian consulate is made online on the website of the diplomatic mission. You choose the date convenient for you and follow the instructions described on the website, as well as fill out the necessary forms. If you have difficulty completing the forms, or if you don’t have any documents requested by the consulate (for example, birth, marriage or divorce certificates), you can contact Carina Duval Law Office for the correct filling of the necessary forms, the restoration of documents in Russia, as well as the execution of all kinds of powers of attorney.
However, to get the passport itself, you will not be able to apply anywhere except for the Russian consulate (the only alternative is a personal trip to Russia). When you see advertisements for companies offering passports without a personal appearance at the Russian consulate, remember that this is illegal, and using the services of such firms, you become accomplices in the crime they commit.
After submitting documents to the Russian consulate, you will have to wait for the passport to be issued, on average it takes two to three months, after which you can either receive the Russian passport in person at the consulate, or (if you leave the application for sending the passport by mail in advance), you will receive it by mail.
Ukrainian passports are issued by the Ukrainian consulate according to a similar scheme. The fundamental difference is only that Ukrainian passports are not sent by mail, and you will have to visit the consulate a second time without fail.
The column was prepared by a lawyer, a notary public, an expert in international law Karina Duval.
Attorney registration: # 78 / 857
NYS registration: #4775086
Notary public, registration: 02DU6376542
You can ask your lawyer a question by mail: email@example.com or get advice by phone:
- in the USA: (212) 205-2211
- in Russia: + 7-495-662-8721
ForumDaily is not responsible for the content of blogs and may not share the views of the author. If you want to become a column author, send your materials to firstname.lastname@example.org
Your question Karine Duval
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 1 [name] => Miscellaneous [taxonomy] => category [slug] => no_theme)Miscellaneous
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 2942 [name] => citizenship [taxonomy] => post_tag [slug] => grazhdanstvo)citizenship
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 16228 [name] => Columns [taxonomy] => category [slug] => bloggers)loudspeakers
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 27222 [name] => Karina Duval [taxonomy] => post_tag [slug] => karina-dyuval)Karina Duval
Read also on ForumDaily:
Let's face the crisis together and support each other
No one in the world expected a coronavirus pandemic, but she came in disrupting the usual rhythm of life and work of billions of people, causing panic and uncertainty about tomorrow.
ForumDaily also faced financial difficulties due to the loss of some advertisers due to the economic downturn and quarantine. But we are not reducing the number of materials and the mode of operation, since we want our readers to receive timely and up-to-date information in this difficult time. In addition, we support Local small businesses in the USA that suffer the most.
But ForumDaily is also a small business. Despite the loss of part of the income, we are doing our best to ensure that you are informed and armed with all the necessary knowledge to counter the pandemic and resolve other important issues during quarantine.
To maintain this rhythm of work, we need your help. We will be grateful for any amount that you are willing to allot to support our team.
Let's face the crisis together!
Security of contributions is guaranteed by the use of the highly secure Stripe system.
Always yours, ForumDaily!
Do you want more important and interesting news about life in the USA and immigration to America? Subscribe to our page in Facebook. Choose the option "Priority in the show" - and read us first. And don't forget to subscribe to ForumDaily Woman and ForumDaily New York - there you will find a lot of interesting and positive information.