Uber and Lyft May End Operations in California: What You Need to Know
Uber and Lyft say they may close their California operations on Friday, August 21. If that happens, they plan to not resume transportation until at least November, when voters give their opinion on Proposition 22, their initiative to retain their workers as independent contractors. Writes about it SFChronicle.
The possible stop stems from a lawsuit between the state of California and the city's attorneys of San Francisco, San Diego and Los Angeles, which said Uber and Lyft were evading AB5 state jobs law by hiring drivers as independent contractors. The state won a temporary case in which drivers can be transferred to another category on August 21.
Meanwhile, the companies are running a massive PR campaign, emailing passengers about the impending threat and urging them to support Proposition 22 to continue service.
The mayors of San Jose and San Diego have called on California courts and lawmakers to decide to keep the services running. San Diego Mayor Kevin Falconer and San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo, Republican and Democrat, respectively, said they feared the impact of the decision on workers and passengers.
“This sudden disappearance of jobs and transportation options will only exacerbate the economic crisis our country is experiencing during this historic pandemic and recession,” they wrote.
- In contrast, Attorney General Xavier Becerra, who is leading the lawsuit against the companies, believes they are trying to "prevent any consequences of their collective years of illegal behavior."
Answers to Frequently Asked Questions
Why Uber and Lyft May End Passenger Services on Aug 21
The bold step was their response to a preliminary injunction ordering them to immediately reclassify their drivers as employees. High Court Justice Ethan Shulman issued the decree on Aug. 10 but delayed execution by 10 days.
The companies filed an appeal against the injunction and asked the appellate court to suspend the order while the appeal was pending, which could take many months. If the appellate court overturns the injunction, companies will continue to provide services. If they refuse to do so, the companies will stop serving.
What will happen to Uber Eats
Uber's food delivery service was unaffected by the injunction and will continue to operate as usual.
Why Uber and Lyft can't just comply with an injunction
The companies say they cannot hire tens of thousands of drivers as employees "at the touch of a button." It is also likely that they do not want to create a precedent showing that they can operate within a hiring model, since a large part of their Proposition 22 is that it will be nearly impossible to hire drivers for their business.
Can service suspension be an empty threat
They have done this before. The companies left Austin, TX in 2016 due to the city's requirement to have their drivers fingerprinted. They returned a year after successfully lobbying for state law, which they found more favorable.
How big a financial blow this will be for Uber and Lyft
Companies have already witnessed a sharp drop in travel volumes during the pandemic, with consumers staying at home and drivers fearing contamination.
Is it too difficult for them to hire drivers?
They had two years to prepare for this, as Judge Schulman noted, as a 2018 California Supreme Court decision called Dynamex made it difficult for companies to classify workers as independent contractors. Lawyers suing them also note that they already have the infrastructure to hire drivers and pay them like employees.
Why they don't want drivers to be employees
It is much more expensive - plus 30% to labor costs. In addition, companies prefer the flexibility of the freelance model and say many workers do too. With employment, they say, travel prices will rise and service will decline in many areas. So, they say, they will have to shift to hiring full-time drivers and assigning them to tough shifts, while throwing legions of people overboard who work just a few hours from time to time to earn extra income.
Can companies leave California permanently if Proposition 22 does not work and a court order forces them to reclassify drivers
They are unlikely to leave the country's most populous state, which accounts for a significant portion of their income, forever. Before the pandemic, California accounted for 9% of Uber rides worldwide. This is even more important for Lyft, which does not operate overseas outside of Canada and has no business other than travel. Before the pandemic, California accounted for 21% of Lyft's trips, and now California accounts for 16% of trips.
How They Can Continue to Work in California Under the Employment Model
The companies are reported to be exploring a fleet model where they would hire third parties to operate the fleet to carry out trips. Then the fleet operators will be responsible for hiring drivers. Uber said it is similar to its original Uber Black service "with higher prices and less reliability."
Why California is targeting companies
California regulators and union organizers say independent contractor drivers and couriers are used in non-routine work situations that lack the protection and benefits associated with employment.
What companies want
Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, Postmates and Instacart have spent at least $ 110 million on Proposition 22, which seeks to retain employees as independent contractors but still qualify for some minimum earnings and some perks.
How did it start
A 2018 California Supreme Court ruling called Dynamex made it harder for companies to claim workers are independent contractors. The court relied on the ruling that employees must be employees, unless they work without the control of the employing organization or work outside the normal operating mode of the employing organization.
What happened next
Dynamex prompted the California legislature to pass AB5, a new jobs law that went into effect on January 1. In a sense, AB5 has expanded Dynamex to apply it to other aspects of employment, not just wage claims.
Why Uber and Lyft say AB5 is not one of them
Both companies refer to themselves as “technology platforms,” not transportation companies. Their argument is what this means: drivers don't play a key role in their business.
Why Concert Companies Can't Hire Employees
Both AB5 and the Dynamex decision explicitly state that companies can allow employees to set their own hours of work and reject or accept assignments. Giant companies, on the other hand, need schedules to provide enough drivers when demand is high.
Are there any cities in which companies work with the schedule of drivers
Last year, New York introduced minimum wages for Uber and Lyft drivers. Both companies have responded by limiting how long drivers can work so that there are not too many of them in low demand. Uber allows drivers to request guaranteed shifts in advance, prioritizing those who drive the most. Lyft only allows access to drivers if there is sufficient demand for rides in their area. However, Lyft has put these changes on hold since the start of the pandemic.
Do drivers want to become wage earners
Drivers are a huge, scattered group. Their survey was not conducted using a methodology that ensures that the responses are representative. However, RideShare Guy interviewed drivers via email and social media channels. Of the 734 drivers who took part in the survey, 71% said they want to remain independent contractors, and 17% want to work as employees.
Is there an alternative for Uber and Lyft
Social network users Quora shared a few options you can use instead of Uber and Lyft. Some people advise to choose LibreTaxi. LibreTaxi does not take any commission fees, operates as a non-profit company.
Also users mention Rydehub. It is a free travel app where users can set their own prices. It is currently in beta, and Uber and Lyft registered drivers cannot work with Rydehub.
Read also on ForumDaily:
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 1 [name] => Miscellaneous [taxonomy] => category [slug] => no_theme)Miscellaneous
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 2393 [name] => California [taxonomy] => post_tag [slug] => kaliforniya)California
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 13032 [name] => Uber [taxonomy] => post_tag [slug] => uber)Uber
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 13992 [name] => Likbez [taxonomy] => category [slug] => poleznaja-informatsija)Educational program
stdClass Object ([term_id] => 17171 [name] => Lyft [taxonomy] => post_tag [slug] => lyft)Lyft
Do you want more important and interesting news about life in the USA and immigration to America? Subscribe to our page in Facebook. Choose the "Display Priority" option and read us first. Also, don't forget to subscribe to our РєР ° РЅР ° Р »РІ Telegram - there are many interesting things. And join thousands of readers ForumDaily Woman и ForumDaily New York - there you will find a lot of interesting and positive information.