Millions of immigrants and U.S. citizen children could be left without social benefits and health care due to a new public charge rule.
On July 16, 2026, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security approved a new rule. It reinterprets a provision of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Act of 1882 that allows immigration officers to deny applications to those they deem potentially in need of public assistance, or "public charge," writes The Conversation.
Imagine this: It's 2023; a woman, let's call her Jessica, and her husband, Pedro, make the difficult decision to leave Venezuela for the United States after becoming targets of political persecution. Shortly after arriving, they apply for asylum.
While their case winds its way through the immigration system, Jessica and Pedro are thrilled to learn they're expecting a baby. But the couple is concerned about the cost of prenatal care. Their work on a fruit farm doesn't provide health insurance, so they can't afford the cost themselves.
On the subject: The US has changed the asylum application process: cases will be sent directly to court, without interviews.
They learn about a government program that provides free prenatal care, but friends and colleagues warn them to be careful about accepting any government assistance—it could affect their immigration status.
Ultimately, the couple refuses medical treatment. Jessica feels well until the last trimester of her pregnancy, but she goes into premature labor and undergoes an emergency hysterectomy. It is later discovered that the complications may have been caused by pesticide exposure at work—and could have been avoided if she had been warned during her prenatal checkup.
Months later, they learn that participating in the prenatal care program would not have made any difference to their asylum claim.
New immigration rule
Stories like this happen very often.
Approximately one in seven immigrants in the country fails to apply for government benefits, even if they are eligible. These programs include, for example, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which helps people buy food, and Medicaid, the federal health insurance program for low-income people.
Many immigrants fear that participating in such programs, even if they qualify, will make it more difficult for them to remain in the country legally.
Often these concerns are unfounded, as historically the state has only punished immigrants for using certain types of assistance.
However, the situation may change soon: on July 16, 2026, the US Department of Homeland Security approved a new rule. It slightly alters the provision of the Immigration and Refugee Act of 1882 that allows immigration officers to deny applications to those they deem potentially in need of government assistance.
The Department of Homeland Security already revised the public charge law during Trump's first term.
Changes introduced by the second Trump administration remove any restrictions on immigration officers' authority to consider the use of public benefits by green card applicants and their relatives when assessing whether a person can become a so-called public charge.
When the policy takes effect on September 18, immigration officers will be able to consider an immigrant's use of any government programs when reviewing applications for permanent resident status, better known as a green card.
If the applicant's relatives received benefits, this may also be taken into account when assessing their financial situation—this approach was not previously used.
What will change
While many categories, such as refugees, will be exempt from the new rule, it is expected to still leave more immigrants feeling they have to choose between receiving health care and their chances of having their immigration application approved – with potential consequences for their health.
This policy change is highly likely to be challenged in court: as an abuse of Department of Homeland Security authority, as an "arbitrary and unreasonable" measure under the Administrative Procedure Act, and as a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment—the very grounds on which the 2019 public charge rule was challenged.
How the Clinton Administration Defined Public Charge
Despite various interpretations, the public charge law has essentially always had the same goal: to prevent immigrants who might become dependent on public assistance from obtaining permanent status. However, after 1882, it was applied inconsistently. This was partly because the concept of public charge itself was not clearly defined for a long time—until the Clinton administration.
In 1996, when Congress restricted access to public benefits and tightened immigration laws, the public charge provision was changed: immigration officers were required to consider an applicant's age, health, marital status, income and assets, educational level, and vocational skills when assessing whether he or she could become a public charge.
In addition, officers had to consider whether the applicant had a guarantor who had signed a financial guarantee, that is, who had undertaken to support him if he was unable to provide for himself.
These changes caused widespread confusion. In response, the Clinton administration issued clarifications in 1999, defining a public charge immigrant as someone "primarily dependent on the state for their livelihood."
Under these clarifications, use of only three programs was taken into account: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, Supplemental Security Income, and Medicaid—and only for long-term care.
One of the goals of these clarifications was to improve public health by encouraging eligible immigrants to take advantage of programs that provide health care, access to nutritious food, and affordable housing.
The first Trump administration
Two decades later, the first Trump administration changed the public charge policy. In 2019, immigration officers were instructed to consider a broader range of programs, including Medicaid eligibility, food assistance, and housing subsidies.
The policy was challenged in the courts, leading to intermittent implementation.
In 2021, the Biden administration abandoned its legal defense of this policy and repealed it. In 2022, a new rule was adopted, codifying the 1999 clarifications.
In effect, this has reinstated the narrower interpretation of public charge that had been in effect since the late 1990s.
Biden has restored his previous approach.
Historically, green card denials due to public charges have been rare. According to the Migration Policy Institute, the rate was less than 1% during Trump's first term.
Furthermore, immigration officers previously disregarded benefits received by applicants' relatives, including so-called blended families, which included both U.S. citizens and stateless immigrants. An estimated 6 million U.S. citizen children live in such families.
The 2022 rules explicitly stated that relatives' use of benefits should not be counted. Trump's new policy changes this approach.
For example, an immigration officer might view a U.S. citizen child's participation in Medicaid as a sign of the parent's financial instability and deny a green card on that basis.
Given that the expansion of public charge policies under the first Trump administration led to many eligible immigrants no longer receiving them, the current changes are expected to do the same—at a risk to the health of the immigrants themselves and their families.
You may be interested in: top New York news, stories of our immigrants and helpful tips about life in the Big Apple - read it all on ForumDaily New York
What's at stake now
These changes will likely affect many immigrants who are already unsure whether it is more important to take advantage of government assistance or improve their chances of staying in the United States.
The consequences will affect all family members that include immigrants, regardless of their legal status.
Therefore, immigrants whose green card applications are pending are advised to consult with an attorney knowledgeable in public charge matters before deciding whether to enroll in government programs or not. This will allow them to obtain the necessary information and make the best decision for their family's health and future.
Read also on ForumDaily:
In September, green card applicants will be penalized for using benefits.
The Trump administration will deny green cards to immigrants who use public assistance.
How Trump's Immigration Restrictions Are Creating Problems for Spouses of US Citizens
Subscribe to ForumDaily on Google NewsDo you want more important and interesting news about life in the USA and immigration to America? — support us donate! Also subscribe to our page Facebook. Select the “Priority in display” option and read us first. Also, don't forget to subscribe to our РєР ° РЅР ° Р »РІ Telegram and Instagram- there is a lot of interesting things there. And join thousands of readers ForumDaily New York — there you will find a lot of interesting and positive information about life in the metropolis.

















