A Ukrainian woman who worked for Fox News died near Kyiv; her parents are suing the channel for money.
The award-winning Fox News war correspondent Benjamin Hall also played a significant role in the story of the Ukrainian journalist's death, putting his colleagues at mortal risk in pursuit of spectacular footage, writes NPRNow the girl's parents are suing the TV channel.
Two years ago, when Fox News gathered hundreds of advertisers and industry executives at Manhattan's Hammerstein Ballroom, war correspondent Benjamin Hall took center stage.
"From Ukraine to the Middle East and here at home, dedicated Fox News journalists are working to keep Americans informed, no matter the risk," Hall declared.
Hall knows the dangers firsthand. During the first weeks of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, his group was near Kyiv. A Russian airstrike struck a car carrying journalists.
Hall nearly died. He lost his right leg below the knee, most of his left foot, and an eye.
On the subject: Veterans of an elite British Army unit are training Russians for the war in Ukraine.
Two years after the attack, Hall took to the stage wearing prosthetics and a suit whose pants ended just above his knees. The audience gave him a standing ovation.
"These stories need to be told from the ground," Hall said then. "They need a human perspective. We need to be witnesses."
But at what cost?
Although Hall was seriously injured, he was luckier than others. The attack killed four of his companions that day: two Ukrainian soldiers serving as guides, Pierre Zakrzewski, a Fox cameraman, and Alexandra Kuvshinova, known as Sasha. The 24-year-old Ukrainian had just joined the group as a producer and translator.
Fox called the deaths a tragedy and honored the victims. However, two multi-million dollar lawsuits blame the network for the incident.
One of these lawsuits was filed by Kuvshinova's parents, who directly accuse Hall. The family's claims are supported by two high-risk area security consultants who worked for Fox News in Ukraine. They claim that Fox News and its star correspondent ignored repeated and persistent warnings to stay away from the danger zone outside Kyiv's city limits.
"If Benji had been taken out of the equation, this would never have happened," assured Aaron King, one of those consultants. Another consultant, Shane Thomson, joined the Kuvshinov family's lawsuit.
Fox News issued a statement: "Ben Hall was the victim of this brutal attack in a war zone, and the attempt to shift blame onto him is deeply shameful."
Hall wrote a memoir, published a year after the tragedy, in which he acknowledged his willingness to take the risk. That same year, he told his story in a Fox documentary.
Two words define the essence of the allegations in the Kuvshinov family's lawsuit against Fox and Hall: ambition and negligence.
Fox calls the deaths a tragedy but denies responsibility
Covering any armed conflict is inherently dangerous. The dangers are often unobvious, and the boundaries of combat zones are undefined. Journalists reporting on wars die.
But the Kuvshinovs and their lawyers say what happened to their daughter could have been prevented.
"This danger could have been easily avoided; they were warned about it specifically: they were told the exact time and place where they shouldn't go," says Stephen Humphreys, the lawyer for the Kuvshinovs and Thomson.
In its court filings regarding the Kuvshinovs' lawsuit, Fox acknowledges the deaths of Kuvshinova and Zakrzewski. However, the network challenges the plaintiffs' claims on technical and legal grounds.
"We continue to mourn the loss of Pierre Zakrzewski and Sasha Kuvshinova, but we will defend ourselves against the inaccurate allegations in this lawsuit," Fox said.
"The safety of our journalists has always been our number one priority, and we are incredibly grateful to the Fox News journalists who covered the war in Ukraine and remain committed to reporting from the region," the statement continued.
At the beginning of 2022, it was not known that Hall would end up in Kyiv.
A dual British-American citizen, Hall writes in his memoirs that at the beginning of World War II, his father's family was living in the Philippines. Japanese troops captured Hall's grandfather, and his grandmother and other relatives were executed. Hall's father, then a boy, was rescued by American troops.
Describing the fighting, Hall writes: "I saw a lot of death, had guns pointed at my head, had terrible dreams, and all of it was an echo of what my father had experienced in Manila."
In his early twenties, Hall bounced from one hot spot to another, working as a freelance reporter for publications like Vice and Esquire, as well as Fox.
The first time he saw a man die was in Misrata, Libya, in 2011. In his memoir, Saved, Hall says he had a choice: look away or make a story.
"I didn't have time to consider all the moral aspects. I could either keep filming or stop, and I chose to keep filming," he wrote, adding that he had just escaped death himself.
Returning to London, Hall realized a profound change had occurred within him: "I learned I could manage my fear and continue to face danger. I learned that the hellish horrors of Misurata weren't enough to stop me from traveling to war zones. And I learned that my ordinary, civilized life would never be the same again."
Years later, his colleague Trey Yingst would call Hall's reporting the "gold standard" of war zone reporting for the network.
But there was at least one warning sign. In a sworn affidavit filed in the Kuvshinovs' lawsuit, former Fox News international producer Phil Ittner stated that he had previously filed a formal internal complaint: Hall's behavior in Syria put colleagues at risk.
"Ben Hall was an adrenaline junkie," Ittner noted in his testimony. "I feared he was putting promotions ahead of the safety of the team he worked with." Ittner demanded that Hall be removed from the field.
In 2015, Hall promised his girlfriend, Alicia Moeller, that he wouldn't take any risks. They soon married. He moved to a full-time job at Fox's London bureau, which still involved covering conflicts and upheavals. But in 2021, Hall moved to Washington to cover the US State Department.
"I made the final decision to leave the front lines," Hall admitted. "Changing my professional life turned out to be much more difficult than I thought: the pull of distant wars never weakened or disappeared. But I understood that new paths were opening up before me."
This new journey lasted about four months.
On February 24, 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin announced the invasion of Ukraine. Hall received a call from a Fox News executive asking if he would cover the war. As he wrote, "I understood my obligations to Alicia and her family and knew I had to avoid putting myself in dangerous situations."
And yet Benjamin went to Ukraine.
From Washington to Lviv
Four days after the Russian invasion began, Hall arrived in Lviv. The journey from Poland had been grueling.
He began reporting and hosting a program that aired nightly on Fox. But the main events unfolded hundreds of kilometers to the east.
Fox had organized coverage of the events from Kyiv with a group of journalists, and now, as the risk increased, it was withdrawing its producers. Only a small group remained.
Nevertheless, Fox gathered all its journalists in Lviv for a Zoom call. The executives hoped to send one more correspondent to Kyiv.
"We all wanted to go, including me," Hall wrote. He was the one invited.
His wife tried to persuade him not to go, Benjamin writes. He assured her everything would be fine.
Fox had a team of security contractors in high-risk areas. These consultants typically have military backgrounds. They provide advice, physical protection, and medical care. They can also restrain journalists willing to take risks for a story.
Aaron King was one of Fox's security consultants for high-risk areas. He says that, along with Hall's wife and another Fox security consultant, he discouraged Hall from going to Kyiv.
"There was no point in him going there," King emphasized. "And I asked him what he thought he would accomplish that other groups hadn't by now."
King said it was like any mission in a war zone: you weigh the risks against the potential reward.
"He took about ten seconds to process what I told him, shrugged, and said, 'Oh, I'm going anyway,'" King reported him as saying. "I never saw Benjamin again."
In his book, Hall described his overwhelming desire to come to Kyiv: "I couldn't refuse the offer to go to Kyiv and continue reporting from there," he wrote in Saved. "It was, in a sense, the culmination of everything I'd worked on and all the risks I'd taken. This was a big story, a war that could change the world, alter the course of history. That was who I was, and I was preparing myself for this."
Among those Hall encountered when he arrived in Kyiv was Sasha Kuvshinova, Fox's new Gen Z fixer.
The motto on her Facebook page is written in English: "If you never try, you never know."
Her other social media accounts are also full of life: music and film festivals, her photo shoots, a trip to Tuscany, childhood photos, her cat named Zephyr.
Since February 2022, after the Russian invasion, her social media pages have become more somber. When a Russian missile struck Kyiv's main TV tower, she wrote on Instagram: "Glory to Ukraine!"
Kuvshinova's mother, Irina Mamaisur, and father, Andrei Kuvshinov, spoke proudly of their daughter. She learned to read at age three, mastered English by 11, and, according to her mother, her talent for translation manifested itself very early.
As a teenager, Kuvshinova assisted foreign reporters during the Orange Revolution.
It was then that she met Zakrzewski, a Fox video journalist.
When Fox asked her to help cover the looming war in early 2022, she eagerly agreed.
"I'll be honest, I was very excited," her father said. "I thought working for such a huge, influential company would be a great experience. It's an interesting topic, interesting people."
"She was delighted," the mother recalls. "She said, 'I've already found my profession.'"
Hall arrived in the Ukrainian capital on March 2.
The Fox crew checked into the InterContinental Kyiv Hotel, a luxury hotel in the historic center of the Ukrainian capital. Film crews from other television networks were also staying there. Hall ran into some acquaintances: Yingst and Zakrzewski, a top-notch video journalist.
Kuvshinova also moved into the hotel. As a fixer for Fox, she maintained contact with Ukrainian military and government officials and scouted locations and scenes for filming. She spoke the language and knew how things worked there. Kuvshinova often sent her parents reassuring messages, such as informing them that she had returned from a trip to the war zone.
"She said, 'Mom, don't worry. Our teams are working with highly experienced security specialists,'" recalled her mother, Irina Mamaisur.
At the end of each day, the group held what they called an "evening prayer." The team reviewed the next day's plans and discussed logistics with Fox producers and security consultants. Senior producers from London and Jerusalem, and even executives from New York, participated in the call.
Every assignment, especially one involving travel to the front lines, had to be approved by a senior TV executive or security officer.
Thomson testified that the staff were "exhausted by stress and overwork" even before Hall's arrival and began "working to the point of complete exhaustion." The addition of another reporter, he said, placed an additional burden primarily on Kuvshinova.
At first, Hall writes, he continued broadcasting live from the balcony of his hotel room. But he wanted more.
In recent decades, the number of armed conflicts covered has increased. Journalist associations and media outlets have begun to pay much greater attention to journalists' safety and meticulous assignment planning. Many reporters are required to undergo "hostile environment training" before covering conflicts.
Williams chairs the Rory Peck Trust, which provides funding and training to help freelance journalists working in dangerous areas stay safe. The trust also supports the families of reporters who have been injured or killed in such circumstances.
Williams said the dangers of war reporting cannot be completely eliminated. Shortly after the 2022 attack on the Fox news crew, CNN correspondent Ben Wedeman and his colleagues were nearly attacked while filming a report in Bucha, a northwestern suburb of Kyiv.
"In such vast open spaces, it seems like the Russians are far away," Vedeman said in his report. "That's not true."
In 2022 alone, 28 journalists were killed in conflict zones around the world, according to UNESCO.
Overall, Williams warned: "When correspondents or groups become less aware of the danger they face and become too comfortable with risk, it's time to remove them."
In her last publicly available Facebook post, Kuvshinova wrote about people fleeing Irpen.
Russian troops blew up an evacuation train carrying people. The railway tracks were also blown up.
In February-March 2022, the most dangerous places in the Kyiv region were the Zhytomyr highway, Bucha, Irpen, Gostomel, Makarov, and the north of the Vyshgorod district.
It was in this area northwest of Kyiv that Kuvshinova died.
On March 12, high-risk area security consultant Shane Thomson drove with Trey Yingst in the same direction but was stopped short at a checkpoint in the northwest suburbs.
According to him, there were Ukrainian soldiers standing nearby and a chain of trenches stretched out, and a kilometer ahead, other fighters were fighting the Russians: “We were relatively safe.”
And then we had to forget about safety.
"The turning point for me was shelling right next to me," Thomson said. "Mines were flying over us. We took cover and then drove away."
Despite the danger, several television channels have already shown dramatic footage from the area. Fox wanted more footage of refugees fleeing Irpin.
"Behind the refugees in the frame, there's a city and smoke. You can hear gunfire and explosions. They needed the atmosphere of the moment," Thomson explained.
But the risks were real. British veteran Dale Sutton, who fought alongside Ukrainian troops, wrote to security consultants in high-risk areas that it was too dangerous to take journalists to Irpin. Russian troops were stationed in the area, some of whom were posing as film crews.
Sutton confirmed Thomson's words. "This is a completely no-go zone. It's the hottest place you'll ever find," he recalled telling Thomson and King. "You have no business here."
Thomson claims in the lawsuit that tensions were mounting between Fox journalists and their security consultants. King, who advised them from Lviv, recounted the same story.
At "evening prayer," Thomson claims to have vetoed a proposed trip to Irpin. He claims that Fox News CEO Susan Scott participated in the call. Fox counters that Thomson has no evidence that Scott directed the network's team's movements in Ukraine.
After the story was first published, Fox News reported: "Scott was not involved in any calls that determined the movements of teams on the ground in Ukraine and would not have handled such editorial matters at the CEO level."
The next day, March 13, Russian troops spread throughout the region. They captured Bucha and half of Irpin, where they shot and killed American documentary filmmaker Brent Reno and wounded his colleague. The mayor of Irpin publicly warned journalists: don't come. It's too dangerous.
After all this, the conclusion at the "evening prayer" on the evening of the 13th was clear, according to the plaintiffs' documents: remain within the boundaries of Kyiv. According to Thomson, the surrounding suburbs were closed to travel.
"There was no way we were going there," Thomson assured NPR. "No way. Not after the credible intelligence we had and everything that had happened before. Everything matched up perfectly. There were no gray areas."
It's unclear how exactly the group came up with the backup plan. According to Thomson, Kuvshinova suggested filming at the defensive line that Ukrainian defense forces were building in Kyiv along the highway to Irpin.
"It was a kind of compromise: on the one hand, the group was pressured to go to Irpin, on the other, they had to stay within the city limits of Kyiv and outside the equipped defensive positions," Thomson stated in a sworn affidavit.
The Kuvshinovs and Thomson claim the trip was organized at Hall's direction, and that Fox executives, who were monitoring the events from New York, supported it.
In a lawsuit filed in the UK by Zakrzewski's widow, Michelle Ross-Stanton, she also claims that by March 13, it was clear that Irpin was unsafe, and Fox failed to heed the warning signs or recognize them. She believes the network had a responsibility to ensure her husband's safety.
In his own statement to the court in the Kuvshinov case, Hall claims that Zakrzewski was supposed to be responsible for liaising with Fox regarding security and logistics on March 14. Hall claims he is unaware of anyone consulting with New York on March 14.
The assignment was simple, Hall wrote in his memoirs: "Pierre and I decided to go to the defensive trenches that were being dug in Kyiv and find a story there."
What happened on March 14
The next day, Zakrzewski, Hall, and Kuvshinova boarded a white minivan near the hotel. They planned to drive along the highway to the checkpoint Ukrainian forces had set up just outside the city limits.
In his book, "Saved," Hall describes how carefully they planned everything: "Pierre and I knew how we would film the complex trench system the Ukrainians were building in Kyiv. We had a clear intention of staying away from the front lines and the fighting, staying within the city limits, and only reporting on the trenches inside Kyiv."
Security consultant Jock Gordon was with them. Thomson stayed behind. According to Thomson, the original driver refused to go, citing danger. The group hired another.
They were accompanied by two Ukrainian soldiers in a separate vehicle. In "Saved," Hall writes that these soldiers were organized by an army press officer at Kuvshinova's request. The parents' lawsuit alleges that military command did not sanction this escort, and the soldiers were moonlighting as security guards.
When they arrived at the trenches, the group saw Ukrainian soldiers shooting at targets, but they were not allowed to film.
"I tried to negotiate with the soldiers through Sasha, but they stood their ground," we read in Hall's memoirs. "Our plan to explain the strategic trench system failed."
But there was no need to return empty-handed. Two of the soldiers accompanying them suggested they continue on to the neighboring suburb of Gorenka, Hall reported. The village, he wrote, "had recently been destroyed by Russian troops, and the day before, the same Ukrainian soldiers who had accompanied the Fox crew had driven the New York Times crew there."
The area, as reported in "Saved," was "abandoned except for a few Ukrainian troops. Russian troops, as we understood it, were no closer than thirty miles [about 48 km] away and were not moving in our direction."
Fox's lawyers explained: "The crux of this allegation is that Hall believed the location was safer than it actually was, and was as mistaken in that regard as the Ukrainian soldiers who transported the group."
The Kuvshinovs and Thomson deny this. Their lawyers believe it's reasonable to conclude that Hall's statement "was patently and demonstrably false from the outset."
The lawsuit against Fox and Hall alleges something else about that highway trip.
The white minibus carrying the journalists had the word "press" written in large letters on the hood and sides, which could have made it a target for Russian troops. Two Ukrainian soldiers wanted everyone to travel in their smaller vehicle, but it only had three empty seats.
According to the lawsuit, Hall said Gordon, the security consultant responsible for protecting the group that day, would have to be left behind and Kuvshinova would be hired instead, as she was the only one who spoke Ukrainian.
Thomson claims Gordon asked Zakrzewski to turn on a live feed so Fox colleagues in New York and London could see his location. A photo posted to Fox's WhatsApp group that day shows Zakrzewski doing just that as the group drove in a military vehicle past a checkpoint and the city limits into Kyiv's disputed northwestern suburbs.
Attack "out of nowhere"
How far they traveled is disputed in court. In any case, having finished photographing the destruction, the group turned back toward Kyiv.
The attack took place on a suburban stretch of road near warehouses and a car service center.
“The first missile came out of nowhere and landed about 30 feet [9 meters] in front of us. Pierre immediately yelled, ‘Back up! Back up!’ The car was stuck. We couldn’t back up, and Pierre yelled again, ‘Get out of the car! Everybody get out of the car!’ And the next second, the second missile hit right in front of the left side of the car. After that, everything went black for me,” Hall said in March 2023.
"I was in the dark. I felt nothing and saw nothing. I had a piece of shrapnel in my eye and a piece of shrapnel the size of a matchbox in my neck. I passed out. I was dead," Hall concluded.
In his memoirs, he names two people who helped him escape the car before it was destroyed by another strike. The first was Zakrzewski: according to Hall, he opened the car door and ordered him out. The second was his young daughter, Honor: Hall heard her voice urging him, "Daddy, we have to get out of the car." He then crawled to the nearest car, and a Ukrainian special forces soldier got out and pulled him to safety.
Zakrzewski "extricated himself from the vehicle but suffered a penetrating wound to his upper left leg and bled to death on the side of the road," his widow's lawsuit says.
Kuvshinova and two soldiers did not get out of the car.
Later that day, having found no trace of the group, Thomson and Gordon, two security consultants in Kyiv, began a frantic search. They contacted Ukrainian military and civilian authorities, hospitals, and morgues. They were assisted by journalists and security consultants from other television channels.
Finally, Thomson said, a doctor called and asked if one of the missing men was British. His patient was seriously injured and had a British passport. It was Hall.
Doctors in Kyiv amputated Hall's right leg, but he required much more intensive care, and urgently. He was spirited out of Kyiv like something out of a spy novel.
The operation involved a special rescue team from the private organization Save Our Allies, which worked during curfew, followed by the Polish Prime Minister's train, which carried Hall out of the combat zone, and an air evacuation to a US military hospital in Germany.
Fox News' chief national security correspondent Jennifer Griffin obtained approval from then-Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin for the air evacuation.
And what about the others? To find Zakrzewski and Kuvshynova, Thomson again turned to security consultants from other media outlets. They spoke with sources in the Ukrainian military and intelligence agencies. International journalists in Kyiv joined forces: CNN correspondent Clarissa Ward assisted Yingst from Fox in the search, according to representatives from both networks. All to no avail.
"We tried to locate them using geolocation devices, satellite phones, their iPhones, and we just couldn't," Thomson recalls. The last recorded location was the spot where they were hit.
Finally, the Kyiv city morgue called. Thomson rushed there to identify Zakrzewski. Fox ordered Thomson to take the body to Poland.
The family's anxiety turned to grief
The Kuvshinovs' lawsuit against Fox and Hall is divided into two parts: what led to their daughter's death and how they say they were treated afterward.
They became alarmed when the usual reassuring message didn't arrive after her trip down the highway. Fox didn't clarify what it did in the first days after Sasha Kuvshinova's death.
According to the Kuvshinovs, the TV channel did not do much.
Fox executives did not immediately call to say what they knew.
They didn't send someone who spoke Ukrainian to help with translation.
They did not immediately offer condolences or words of comfort, nor did they show how highly they valued Kuvshinova as a colleague.
"We weren't told anything about the search for Sasha or any investigations," her father, Andrei Kuvshinov, assured NPR. "We weren't told. And it's unclear whether they knew what happened, and if they did, why they didn't tell us."
Moreover, Kuvshinova's parents claim that no one contacted them even on the day of the attack.
The next day, they say, someone from the Fox group in Kyiv called them and offered to pick up their daughter's things.
Kuvshinov told NPR he took this as an ominous sign. He didn't go. The man called back, but his father still didn't go.
The next day, Kuvshinova’s boyfriend, Svyatoslav Yurash, brought them her suitcase from the InterContinental.
According to Kuvshinov, it was People's Deputy Yurash who informed them that their daughter had died.
The two of them followed the film crew's route. First, they were stopped at a checkpoint where the Fox crew was planning to film the trenches.
The commander of the Ukrainian military post said he saw the Fox crew and warned Hall not to go any further, according to Kuvshinov's statement. The journalists went anyway.
Kuvshinov said that he and Yurash continued along the highway following the Fox group's trail. In his written testimony, he stated that on the southern outskirts of Gostomel, on the border with Irpen, they came across the "burnt hulk" of a car.
Hall wrote in a statement to the court that the attack occurred in Gorenka, which is closer to Kyiv than Gostomel: "Everything there was destroyed, obliterated, wiped off the face of the earth. My daughter's body was not there."
The next day, 48 hours after the fatal blow, the Kuvshinovs were told their daughter was in the morgue. They could only identify her by her clothes, "as her body had turned to ashes." For many weeks, they refused to accept this as true, until DNA tests confirmed the result.
"She was murdered," he wrote in English. "I couldn't help but come. I couldn't help but look. I couldn't help but find. I couldn't help but hate her like never before. There will be justice," Yurash wrote on social media.
On March 17, the day after Kuvshinov saw his daughter's remains in the morgue, Fox News' head of human resources sent him an offer to pay her salary and benefits, cover her funeral expenses, and pay "an additional sum of money roughly equal to the insurance payments she would have received had she been a full-time employee," Fox lawyers wrote in court papers.
Since Kuvshinova wasn't a permanent employee, the payment was intended "as a sign of sympathy and goodwill," the network claimed. Furthermore, Fox's court documents claim it paid the family more than the contractually agreed upon amount.
The father claims that Fox hadn't paid her anything at all by the time of his daughter's death. "I didn't know how much fault Fox was," Kuvshinov wrote in his testimony. "I didn't imply or assume that the payment Fox offered three days after Sasha's death and the day after we were officially notified of her death covered any of Fox's fault."
He said he would never have agreed to it. His wife, he said, was devastated and unaware that Fox was seeking such a settlement.
A week later, Fox News CEO Susan Scott emailed the Kuvshinovs condolences in English and Ukrainian.
"There's no pain greater for a parent than the loss of a child. I know Sasha was an absolutely exceptional young woman," Scott wrote. "Many of our reporters and producers told me how talented she was and how much they admired her work and passion."
"Know that we will not forget your daughter and her sacrifice," Scott concluded. "We will honor Sasha in our work, keep her memory in our thoughts, and remember her in our prayers."
On the same day, Fox posted a memorial to Kuvshinova on its website.
On March 27, the television channel sent the documents. Kuvshinov signed them the following day, exactly two weeks after his daughter's death. In court documents, Fox claimed it could not be held legally liable since Kuvshinov signed the document: "A valid contract is the beginning and end of the matter."
Fox's lawyers argued that the network had no legal duty to disclose any facts to Kuvshinov, meaning he had not committed fraud by offering the settlement.
According to the Kuvshinovs, Hall called them once. The gulf between them was too great: the grieving Ukrainians couldn't understand the English the reporter, whose throat was choked with grief, was saying.
In November 2023, Hall returned to Kyiv with Lachlan Murdoch, executive chairman of Fox News' parent company. He and his father, Rupert, control the network as owners.
Hall secured an exclusive interview with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who awarded Hall the Order of Merit, 3rd Class, for his "outstanding personal contribution to strengthening support for Ukraine's independence and territorial integrity." Hall also met with his rescuers to thank them.
Hall and Murdoch had no contact with the Kuvshinovs during their visit. The father said he learned details of his daughter's death only from Thomson, the security consultant, and Humphries, the lawyer, and not from Fox. (Since the start of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Humphries has been a frequent visitor to Kyiv, documenting possible Russian war crimes and lecturing at local law schools. Humphries said this is how he learned about the case.)
They filed the lawsuit in March 2024.
Shane Thomson, a security consultant, joined the girl's parents in their lawsuit against Fox and Hall.
He says that after the attack, some Fox employees insinuated that Thomson's alcohol abuse (he denies drinking) led to the deaths. In a written deposition, he said that SEPAR, the security consulting firm that hired him to work for Fox, fired him a few months after the attack without explanation.
Former Fox security consultant Aaron King confirmed his claims and said Thomson did not abuse alcohol.
In court documents, Fox's lawyers noted that Thomson failed to provide specific examples of the statements he made about him. The network stated that it cannot be held responsible for what is said unofficially about Thomson.
Zakrzewski's widow, Michelle Ross-Stanton, filed a parallel civil suit last year in London, where the couple lived. In it, she claims Fox failed to provide adequate security for the film crew. She sought over $11 million in compensation for the network's failure to protect Zakrzewski.
The lawsuit on behalf of the Kuvshinovs and Thomson raises questions about what evidence counts and whether American law applies to an incident in a war zone thousands of miles from the United States.
The Kuvshinovs' chances of winning their case are slim. They are up against a media empire. In December, Judge Mary Rosado dismissed Rupert Murdoch and Fox News Media CEO Susan Scott as defendants in the case. Rosado also dismissed the lawsuit against HarperCollins, Murdoch's publishing house, which published Hall's memoir, "Saved: A War Reporter's Mission to Make It Home." The judge also dismissed two counts of Thomson's lawsuit.
But some of the charges remained, including those of tortious interference and infliction of emotional distress. Rosado also ruled that the case could proceed to the discovery stage. This means the Kuvshinovs' lawyers will be able to examine internal Fox News correspondence, video recordings, materials, and other evidence.
And the Kuvshinovs' lawyer, Humphreys, believes he has impeccable evidence against Fox and Hall: Hall's own words. Although the publisher of his memoirs is no longer a defendant, the Kuvshinovs' lawyer continues to rely on the book in defending their case.
Fox is appealing Judge Rosado's ruling. He's seeking to have Thomson's remaining charges dismissed. (Following Rosado's retirement this year, a new judge is handling the case.)
Zakrzewski's widow, Michelle Ross-Stanton, is still pursuing her lawsuit against Fox in the British courts. Ross-Stanton noted that Zakrzewski would have turned 60 in August.
Ross-Stanton, a seasoned reporter herself, is assisting France's National Anti-Terrorism Prosecutor's Office. The office has launched a formal war crimes investigation into the deadly attack and is working with Irish and Ukrainian authorities.
The Prosecutor General's Office of Ukraine reported that national police are still conducting a pre-trial investigation into the deaths of Kuvshinova and Zakrzewski, with an eye toward possible criminal prosecution of Russian military personnel.
The day after Kuvshinova's death, her boyfriend, Yurash, signed documents to join the Ukrainian armed forces. He is now a sergeant. In the intervening years, Yurash has married and become a father. He commissioned a sculpture in memory of Kuvshinova.
You may be interested in: top New York news, stories of our immigrants and helpful tips about life in the Big Apple - read it all on ForumDaily New York
A few weeks after her death, another friend of Kuvshinova's, Alexei Gorbach, honored her memory in an online memorial.
"I asked her more than once, 'Alexandra, why do you have to do this?'" Gorbach recounted. "And one day she answered me, 'It's impossible to climb any mountain without risk.' That's why she wanted to be a war correspondent: to be useful, to be at the center of events."
Friends say Kuvshinova's mission to tell the world what's happening to her country remains admirable.
But her parents say those she worked for and trusted failed to protect her.
"Fox treated us shamefully: they disregarded us and didn't respect us," concluded Kuvshinova's mother, Irina Mamaisur. "This world has lost Alexandra Kuvshinova—a musician, poet, athlete, photographer, and the best daughter. It has lost my love."
Read also on ForumDaily:
Ukrainians may soon lose protection in the US: Senators ask Trump to extend it
Trump is ready to ease sanctions against Russia in exchange for the release of political prisoners.
Subscribe to ForumDaily on Google NewsDo you want more important and interesting news about life in the USA and immigration to America? — support us donate! Also subscribe to our page Facebook. Select the “Priority in display” option and read us first. Also, don't forget to subscribe to our РєР ° РЅР ° Р »РІ Telegram and Instagram- there is a lot of interesting things there. And join thousands of readers ForumDaily New York — there you will find a lot of interesting and positive information about life in the metropolis.

















