Half of illegal immigrants got to the USA on legal visas: why they cannot be found and deported
US President Donald Trump focused on preventing illegal crossings of the southern border. But in fact, almost half of those who are illegally in the country entered it with completely legal visas and stayed after the visa expired. Calculating the exact number of such illegal immigrants is very difficult.
Process engineer Eddie O lost his job during the financial crisis that swept South Korea in 1998. With no prospects, he collected all his savings to pay for his family flights to California. He told the US Embassy that he was going on vacation with his relatives. Family issued six-month American visas, says New York Times.
The O family headed to Sunnyvale, a middle-class town in the Silicon Valley of California, where a relative had already rented a small apartment for them: 9 people squeezed into 2 rooms. Oh found a job painting the house, his wife became a waitress, and the children, 11-year-old Eli and 9-year-old Sue, went to school.
“We were constantly in debt. “We tried our best to pay the rent,” said Eli O, who grew up and became an emergency nurse at Stanford University. “Nobody ever thought that we were illegal here because we did not comply with this stereotype.”
They are hardly alone. Family O's workaround to a place of residence in the United States is part of one of America's least widely known immigration stories.
Around 350 000 travelers arrive by air in the United States every day. From Asia, South America and Africa, they come mainly with visas allowing them to travel, study, do business or attend a conference for a permitted period of time. But when their visas expire, some of them fall into the same illegal status that is often associated with migrants appearing on the southern border.
Nearly half of the approximately 11 million undocumented immigrants currently in the country did not go through the desert or the Rio Grande to enter the country; they arrived with a legal visa, passed the check at the airport - and stayed.
Of the approximately 3,5 million undocumented immigrants who entered the country between 2010 and 2017, 65% came with official permission affixed to their passports, according to new data compiled by the Center for Migration Studies. More people came from India during this period than from any other country.
“The big missed story of immigration is that twice as many people entered with a visa than illegally crossed the border in recent years,” said Robert Warren, a demographer who calculated delinquency data from an annual survey of the American Community by the Census Bureau.
Since Trump has called for the hiring of thousands of new border patrol agents and the construction of miles of new fences, federal immigration authorities have allocated relatively few resources to the much larger number of illegal immigrants who have expired.
The Department of Homeland Security said that over the past 2 years it has been possible to slightly reduce the number of visa delinquencies, but enforcement measures are difficult because the authorities are just beginning to gain access to more accurate data about who flew and did not fly out of the country.
According to the migration center, expired immigrants in the United States make up about 46% of 10,7 million illegal immigrants. We are not talking about a huge jump in visa delinquencies - rather, the proportion of such cases has increased amid a huge reduction in the number of border crossings since the 2000 of the year.
The largest number of illegal immigrants - about 1 million - hails from Mexico, a neighboring country with a long history of commercial and family ties and a significant flow of people across the border. But the picture is changing. Between 2010 and 2017, the 330 000 Indians expired their visas - more than guests from any other country. Many expired visas from people from China, Venezuela, the Philippines, Brazil and Colombia.
According to the Center for Migration Studies, many unregistered Asians, including most from India, settled like Osh in Sunnyvale and its environs, about 50 miles southeast of San Francisco.
Apple, LinkedIn, and other tech titans in the region are hiring many of the companies sponsored for legal work visas or permanent residency in the United States. Some of them remain independent programming contractors after the expiration of their visas or after leaving the company that sponsored them for a visa.
But they are only part of the story. Many undocumented Indians in Sunnyvale work in low-skilled jobs to serve their well-off brothers, who often go to Indian supermarkets, snack bars, and clothing stores.
For example, 24-year-old S. Singh works in a diner where a crowd of his compatriots buys lunches. Like most others interviewed for this story, he refused to give his full name, but said he arrived as a 2 tourist a year ago. In nearby Indian grocery stores, Indian workers were placing food on shelves. They did not dare to answer questions, not to mention touching on the topic of their entry. But one of them said that he received a student visa, which expired.
In a closed restaurant, two Indian men and two women slept before dinner on long benches, where visitors would later sit. An Indian engineer Ankit, working on a legal visa to the United States, who saw this picture when he arrived at lunch, suggested that these people did not have documents - just like the Indian who was driving a taxi that brought Ankit to a restaurant.
The government reported that almost 670 000 travelers who arrived by air or sea and were due to leave for the 2018 financial year did not leave the country by 30 September 2018. This number was reduced to almost 415 700 by March 2019 of the year, because many people are delayed for only a few months.
But, according to experts, the development of policies to limit delinquency requires accurate data, and representatives of the National Security still do not have a reliable system to track them.
Most travelers take photographs and fingerprints at US consulates abroad when they receive a visa, and then again upon arrival in the United States. However, customs and border protection still depends on the biographical data provided by the airlines when sending passengers to count those who did not leave on time or did not leave at all.
In 2016, federal officials began working with airlines and airport authorities to establish a biometric gate comparison system. A digital photograph of those who board a plane to leave the country is compared with a photograph taken on arrival.
The program now covers between 4% and 5% of people departing every day, said John F. Wagner, Deputy Assistant Executive Commissioner for Customs and Border Control. In an interview, he said his agency hopes to reach 90% of departing travelers within three years.
The Immigration and Customs Service, which enforces immigration rules in the interior of the country, said priority is given to identifying those who pose a potential threat to national or public security. In fiscal year 2018, the National Security Investigation Unit made 1808 arrests for violating visa deadlines.
Many of those who have expired their visas do not intend to stay in the country illegally, said Kalpana Peddibhotla, an immigration attorney in the San Francisco Bay area.
“They arrived for a certain purpose and lost their status for various reasons, and then realized that there is no simple mechanism to correct violations of their status,” she said.
Graduates from American universities are allowed to stay in the United States for a certain period of time to work, but violating deadlines or making mistakes in immigration forms will automatically make them subject to deportation. Sometimes employers transfer foreign workers to a new place and do not amend their documents as required, which also cancels their legal status.
“They stay because they built their life here, bought houses here, they had children here,” said Peddibhotla.
Among Asians, in particular, being an illegal immigrant means bringing shame to the family. Like some others, the elder Oh, his wife and daughter refused to give an interview for this article, although her daughter was able to help her parents get a green card after she married an American.
“My parents are not proud of breaking the law,” said O, who now also has a green card. “To this day, most of their church friends do not know that they have no documents.”
In places like Sunnyvale, it’s easy for people to hide their immigration status.
“Especially if they are not from Mexico or Latin America, no one suspects that they have no documents,” said Katie Jean, executive director of Immigrants Rising, a law firm that works with young illegal immigrants.
“Their parents encourage them to lower their eyes, not share their stories, or speak out on immigration issues,” Gene said.
Marilyn Omatang left Manila in 2004 with her oldest child, Dean, who was then 12 years old, to join her husband, who had come to California two years earlier.
“She told me we're going to Disneyland,” Dean recalled.
But they had to stay in the United States in order to earn money and provide a child with special needs who needed expensive medical care, as well as to educate three more children who live in the Philippines with relatives.
“Having only a job at 7-Eleven, I could pay for treatment and their education,” said 56-year-old Omatang, who grew up to be a manager. She was fired only after a colleague told the boss that she lives in the United States illegally.
For over 10 years, she has been working as a caregiver for wealthy elderly people in Silicon Valley, never revealing her status and using a different name to report her income to the federal tax authorities.
According to Omatang, one of her employers is a supporter of Trump, who supports a tough approach to illegal immigration.
“I heard her say,“ Just send all these illegal immigrants home, ”says Omatang. “And I thought: if you only knew ...”
Read also on ForumDaily:
We ask you for support: make your contribution to the development of the ForumDaily project
Thank you for staying with us and trusting! Over the past four years, we have received a lot of grateful feedback from readers who helped our materials arrange life after moving to the USA, get a job or education, find a place to live or arrange a child in a kindergarten.
Now we want to ask YOU for support.
High-quality journalism requires serious financial investments and our revenues do not always cover the costs of maintaining the editorial staff, which jeopardizes the continuous operation of the site. We do not introduce a paid subscription, so that Russian-speaking immigrants in the United States can freely receive verified information in their native language. But we will be grateful to you for any amount that you are willing to share so that we can continuously provide useful information to thousands of immigrants.
Security of contributions is guaranteed by the use of the highly secure Stripe system.
Always yours, ForumDaily!
Do you want more important and interesting news about life in the USA and immigration to America? Subscribe to our page in Facebook. Choose the option "Priority in the show" - and read us first. And don't forget to subscribe to ForumDaily Woman - There you will find a lot of positive information.